
The BBB has a warning out about emergency garage door companies inflating "the amount of work needed or the parts needed for repair." So we pulled our own invoices to see what really goes on them when a spring gets replaced.
We went through every finished, billed job in our San Diego service area from late May 2025 to early November 2026. That's 2,584 jobs, and 928 of them have a line for a new torsion spring. Jobs where a spring was only adjusted don't count. Neither do extension springs, or the 4 jobs that also got a new door.
| Also on the invoice | Jobs | Share of 928 |
|---|---|---|
| Bearings | 441 | 47.5% |
| Rollers | 260 | 28.0% |
| Cables | 201 | 21.7% |
| Drums | 162 | 17.5% |
| Torsion tube | 146 | 15.7% |
| Hinges | 22 | 2.4% |
| None of these | 317 | 34.2% |
One job can sit in several rows, which is why that adds up to more than 100%.
So about a third of our spring jobs had none of those parts on the invoice. Bearings were the only extra on 171 jobs. On 125 jobs the tube, drums and cables all changed together.
What the table can't tell you
It shows what's common at one company. It doesn't show what your door needs. An invoice lists the parts and almost never the reason, and our notes rarely fill that in.
So ask about your door.
You can say no
A La Mesa job from spring 2026 billed two springs and bearings. The tech's note: "I told her to replace the rollers she want to think about that."
On some invoices the extras never get billed at all. One from north San Diego in summer 2025 charged for two springs and labor, then listed cables, rollers, tube and end bearings as needing replacement "in the near future," at no charge for the recommendation. That's a fair way to do it. You get the warning and you decide when.
Why it's usually two springs
Of the 928 jobs, 891 show a standard spring size. Going by quantity, 627 got two springs (70.4%) and 247 got one (27.7%). The other 17 got three or four.
If your door has two springs and one broke, you'll probably hear that both should go. That's Clopay's advice too: "If your garage door has two springs, replace both at the same time, even if one is not broken." We go through the tradeoffs in single vs. double springs.
Two sizes, .207 wire by 28 inches and .218 wire by 28 inches, made up 932 of 1,565 sized springs. Have the size written on your invoice. It makes the next repair easier to compare.
What to ask before you say yes
Take each added part one at a time:
- What's wrong with this one, and can you show me?
- What happens if it waits?
Get it in writing. The BBB says a written estimate should detail "the scope of work, materials, and costs." If you want product and labor split out, say so up front. Only 92 of our 928 invoices have a separate labor line.
Ask to see the old parts once they're off the door. For rollers, a Clopay door manual says to look for "broken wheels, bent shafts or worn-out bearings." For cables, Clopay's checklist names cables that are "frayed or have worn strips hanging loose." Bearings are harder to judge by eye, and we didn't find a manufacturer check to point you to, so have the tech show you.
Only look at parts that are already off. DASMA's checklist says not to operate a door with a broken spring, and not to "remove, repair or adjust springs or any door parts."
Questions about a spring repair? Call us at (619) 808-6343.